Dissecting Obamacare Politics...
Near-history, the journalistic
reconstruction of contemporary events, has come to be dominated by two
schools. The first is represented by Michael Lewis... His books have won him many admirers (including
me) because they offer deceptively simple narratives in the service of a
grand canonical theme...The second school is associated with the Washington Post reporter Bob Woodward. Woodwardian history is kaleidoscopic, The
reporter makes many telephone calls and office visits, and reads many
documents. All key players are represented and events detailed. The
approach is sociological: the great theme of the Woodward school is the
interaction of institutions and vested interests. In a Lewis, if you
remove the titles of the characters and simply identify them by their
first names, nothing is lost: an individual’s character, not his
position, is what matters. In a Woodward, the opposite is often true.
Names may be irrelevant; titles tell you what you need to know.
From Malcolm Gladwell's review of “America’s Bitter Pill” by Steven Brill, a book about the Affordable Care Act's construction and "Brill’s attempt at a Woodward." Of course, the old saying comes to mind: "Laws, like sausages, are better off not being watched as they are made."
No comments:
Post a Comment