Friday, January 16, 2015
Brief reprieve...
...Saudi Arabia postpones flogging of blogger Raif Badawi
According to Amnesty International, which has adopted Badawi as a prisoner of conscience, the married father-of-three was removed from his jail cell on Friday morning and taken to the prison clinic for a health check. The doctor concluded that the wounds from last week’s lashings had not yet healed properly and Badawi would be unable to withstand more. He recommended that the flogging be postponed until next week.
Something to think on …
It is my settled opinion, after some years as a political correspondent, that no one is attracted to a political career in the first place unless he is socially or emotionally crippled.
— Auberon Waugh, who died on this date in 2001
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Enduring bond...
...Kolkata Book Fair: The city's love affair with literature
Where there are books, there must be booklifters. In Kolkata, they were censured, but almost indulgently so. One offender caught in the act explained that he had a terminally ill brother whose only solace was reading. A touching story, except that the salesman knew him and pointed out that he was an only child. (He was let off after doing 20 squats for atonement.) Two guilty schoolgirls, sweating and red-faced, got a look over half-moon spectacles, a dressing-down from the stall-owner… and a gift of a book each!
Something to think on …
A learned fool is more a fool than an ignorant fool.
— Moliere, born on this date in 1622
What can one say?
… A look at the writings of Saudi blogger Raif Badawi – sentenced to 1,000 lashes | World news | The Guardian. (Hat tip, Lee Lowe.)
Saudi Arabia is obviously an appalling place. Other nations should have as little to do with it as possible. Everybody should bring their ambassadors home and tell the Saudi ambassadors to go the hell home and stay there until their kingdom figures out how to be civilized.
Saudi Arabia is obviously an appalling place. Other nations should have as little to do with it as possible. Everybody should bring their ambassadors home and tell the Saudi ambassadors to go the hell home and stay there until their kingdom figures out how to be civilized.
Wednesday, January 14, 2015
Exploiting poetry …
… Unquotable Quotes | Capital Commentary. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
The problem with reducing complex texts into pull-quotes, blurbs, and slogans is the same problem political rhetoric tends to have reaching any intelligent, self-respecting audience. The poems of Machado and Stevens are both far more appealing in whole cloth than snippet, because good poetry gives and takes. Good art both shows and doesn’t show; it reveals in part, not in full, lest its seductive power be diminished. And great art contains and, in some way, accounts for death.
On behalf of freedom …
On Sunday, January 25, at 2 PM, The Green Line Café on Locust
will present an open poetry reading to honor the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists, editors and staff who were killed in Paris.
In the spirit of Charlie Hebdo, this will be a reading
of humorous and satirical poems.
The poems may be on any subject, including political content.
You may read original work or the work of another poet.
The Green Line Poetry Series extends its solidarity
and deep sympathy to the brave members of Charlie Hebdo
and to the people of Paris.
Please join us.
Reserve a place among the list of readers by contacting
Leonard Gontarek at gontarek9@earthlink.net or 215-808-9507.
The Green Line Café on Locust is located at 45th & Locust Streets
(southeast corner) in West Philadelphia.
will present an open poetry reading to honor the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists, editors and staff who were killed in Paris.
In the spirit of Charlie Hebdo, this will be a reading
of humorous and satirical poems.
The poems may be on any subject, including political content.
You may read original work or the work of another poet.
The Green Line Poetry Series extends its solidarity
and deep sympathy to the brave members of Charlie Hebdo
and to the people of Paris.
Please join us.
Reserve a place among the list of readers by contacting
Leonard Gontarek at gontarek9@earthlink.net or 215-808-9507.
The Green Line Café on Locust is located at 45th & Locust Streets
(southeast corner) in West Philadelphia.
Back to nature …
… Bryan Appleyard � Blog Archive � Physics: Superstitions and Allegories? (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
… the dangers of relying on maths are obvious. In climate science, for example, mathematical models have repeatedly proved wrong – most spectacularly in their failure to predict the pause in global warming over the last two decades. By the rigorous and effective standard of testing againts nature and falsifiability, superstring theory cannot be science.
But they look smarter!!!
Grade inflation is more prevalent now at private institutions than it is at public ones, according to the study. The mean GPA for both private and public schools in the 1930s was 2.3, or a C+. That number for both types of institutions increased at the same rate until recently. Today, the average GPA at private universities is 3.3, a B+, while that at public colleges is 3.0, a B.Same Performance, Better Grades from The Atlantic
Something to think on …
It is little enough we know and the rest is darkness.
— Hendrik Willem van Loon, born on this date in 1882
Sound thinking …
… Christians Should Get Comfortable With Blasphemy | RealClearPolitics.
The second and more important reason to live and let live, however, is philosophical. It boils down into one simple sentence: The freedom to worship what we want is inextricably linked to the freedom to blaspheme what we want. This is not a new or novel concept. It’s the very bedrock of the ideals of the Enlightenment, from Voltaire onward to America’s founding fathers. What is new, however, is the fact that Christians, long slammed as “intolerant” and “close-minded,” might now be among the leading candidates to take up its banner.
Tuesday, January 13, 2015
Deer and butterflies and...people!
This deer is sexually ambiguous. Biologically female, it is typically able to conceive, bear and nurse fawns. But this doe typically manufactures above-average levels of testosterone, giving it a masculinity expressed through the sprouting of antlers, that crown of bone that bucks—that is, male deer—grow each year ahead of mating season....Anecdotal reports suggest that antlered does are outcasts, wary of bucks and ostracized by other does, which tend to run in small packs.
The Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University has over 3 million specimens in its entomology collection, but one butterfly stands out from the rest. The butterfly is literally one in a million because it exhibits both the physical characteristics of a male and a female.
Anniversary - Caesar Crossing the Rubicon
January 10th 49 BC...
Caesar was staying in the northern Italian city of Ravenna and he had a decision to make. Either he acquiesced to the Senate's command [to disarm] or he moved southward to confront Pompey and plunge the Roman Republic into a bloody civil war. An ancient Roman law forbade any general from crossing the Rubicon River and entering Italy proper with a standing army. To do so was treason. This tiny stream would reveal Caesar's intentions and mark the point of no return.
Poe on writing "The Raven"
Seven tips from his "The Philosophy of Composition" which also had this thought: “the death… of a beautiful woman” is
“unquestionably the most poetical topic in the world.” Open Culture
Marcel Proust, Catholic …
… RORATE CAELI: THE DEATH OF CATHEDRALS - and the Rites for which they were built - by Marcel Proust (first full English translation). (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
… Sculptures and stained-glass windows recover their significance, a mysterious odor once again wafts in the temple, a sacred drama is performed, and the cathedral starts to sing once more. When the government underwrites this resurrection, it is more in the right than when it underwrites the performances in the theaters of Orange, of the Opéra-Comique, and of the Opéra, for Catholic ceremonies have an historical, social, artistic, and musical interest whose beauty alone surpasses all that any artist has ever dreamed, and which Wagner alone was ever able to come close to, in Parsifal—and that by imitation.
Hmm …
… Life After Faith: The Case for Secular Humanism // Reviews // Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews // University of Notre Dame. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
The diversity of religious opinion shows, he says, that the source, whatever it is, of religious opinion is unreliable. Consider whatever cognitive processes it is that produce religious opinion: since those processes produce such a variety of mutually conflicting opinion, much or most of what they produce is false. Hence, those sources must be considered unreliable. And if they are unreliable, Kitcher thinks, the opinions they produce are almost certainly false: "Secularist doubt is prompted by probing the processes that generate specific beliefs about the transcendent. Those processes are so unreliable that all of the conflicting specific religious doctrines are, almost certainly, false" (19).
William James would certainly find it peculiar to argue that the variety of religious experience is proof that religious doctrines are almost certainly false. Moreover, underlying the diversity is some very significant unity. One suspects that the Buddha would be in agreement with Lao Tzu and Heraclitus regarding, respectively, the Tao and the Logos. As D. T. Suzuki pointed out, Meister Eckhart seems to have hit on something remarkably similar to Zen entirely on his own. In fact, the mystics seem almost entirely in agreement with each other.
Something to think on …
Religion is doing; a man does not merely think his religion or feel it, he lives his religion as much as he is able, otherwise it is not religion but fantasy or philosophy.
— George Gurdjieff, born in this date in 1872
Who would've thought?
I spent my time—for that year and a half—in full-on public engagement. I developed a certain comfort level and skill for public speaking. When I began my book tour, I was asked by an organization interested in booking me as a speaker to describe my “message.” I was confounded. I was a novelist and memoirist, I said. I didn’t have a message. Wrong answer. I quickly learned that if I wanted the opportunity to speak in front of audiences larger than the dozen or so who frequent bookstore readings, I would have to reverse-engineer my book in order to unearth some sound bites. As I traveled the country disguised as something of a motivational speaker, I was away from my husband, my young son, my home, my dogs, my desk. At a certain point, I began to see that I was away from my self—the very self that had written the book.
Monday, January 12, 2015
Hmm …
… 'n 1' Editor Mark Greif’s Brilliant Contribution to the History of Ideas – Tablet Magazine. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
That's not what maieutics meant back when I was studying Plato. In the Platonic sense, the teacher is the midwife helping the pupil to give birth to authentic thought. We learn by means of encounter — with our teacher, and with experience.
The question of man was asked over and over again, Greif shows, usually in similar terms. Writers on the subject lamented the decline of Enlightenment ideals, asked where society had gone wrong, and often found the culprit in technology. They called for what Greif calls “re-enlightenment,” a return to the ideals of freedom, reason, and individualism that modern Europe seemed to have abandoned.Yet he finds this discourse generally unimpressive, lacking originality and profundity. The best way to understand it, Greif argues, is as “maieutics.” The word comes from the Greek for “midwife,” and a maieutic argument like the crisis-of-man discourse is less concerned with establishing truth than with eliciting certain responses in the audience. By talking about man, in other words, these mid-century writers hoped to will him into being, at a time when he seemed about to disappear.
New York Magazine's Obama History Project...
53 Historians Weigh In on Barack Obama’s Legacy
...The contributors tilted liberal — that’s academia, no surprise — but we made an effort to create at least a little balance with conservative historians. Their responses often echoed those from the far left: that a president elected on a promise to unite the country instead extended the power of his office in alarming, unprecedented ways...
Something to think on …
There is an ecstasy that marks the summit of life, and beyond which life cannot rise. And such is the paradox of living, this ecstasy comes when one is most alive, and it comes as a complete forgetfulness that one is alive.
— Jack London, born on this date in 1876
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Sigh...
BERLIN (Reuters) - A Hamburg daily that reprinted satirical cartoons from French newspaper Charlie Hebdo was hit by arsonists at the weekend, raising security concerns in Germany on the eve of a planned mass rally against Islam in the city of Dresden.
Lies and cowardice …
… Men Without Chests: How C.S. Lewis Predicted Charlie Hebdo Censorship.
See also: Stop Lying: Media Are Censoring Charlie Hebdo Out Of Fear Of Islam.
See also: Stop Lying: Media Are Censoring Charlie Hebdo Out Of Fear Of Islam.
… It’s absolutely not true that the New York Times cares one whit about the religious (or otherwise) sentiments of peaceful families in Brooklyn. If they did, they wouldn’t run so many depictions of anti-semitic caricatures in stories about anti-semitic caricatures. Or of blasphemous anti-Christian art in stories about blasphemous anti-Christian art. Or of gross ethnic and racial stereotypes in stories about gross ethnic and racial stereotypes. When the New York Times wrote about Catholic outrage over an art exhibit that featured a “black Madonna with a clump of elephant dung on breast & cutouts of genitalia,” that story featured a color photo of the art in question. Heck, it still does. Right there on the web site.
Religion of peace …
… Local artist remains in hiding after Islamic cartoon controversy | Local & Regional | Seattle News, Weather, Sports, Breaking News | KOMO News. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
Vikram sends this along: Denying links of Charlie Hebdo killings to Islam is self-deception.
And my friend and former colleague Trudy Rubin has this in today's Inquirer: Worldview: The world must now confront Salafi teachings.
Vikram sends this along: Denying links of Charlie Hebdo killings to Islam is self-deception.
And my friend and former colleague Trudy Rubin has this in today's Inquirer: Worldview: The world must now confront Salafi teachings.
Because religions are practiced by humans, they have often displayed gross human failings, but just about all the world's faiths except Islam seem to have put aside their former attachment to violence. If Muslims themselves don't do something about that, others are likely to.
Something to think on …
The sovereign cure for worry is prayer.
— William James, born in this date in 1842
Saturday, January 10, 2015
Not getting it …
… 'I AM NOT CHARLIE': Leaked Newsroom Emails Reveal Al Jazeera Fury over Global Support for Charlie Hebdo | National Review Online.
Sorry, guys. Freedom of speech has to do with speech that some or all find offensive. Hardly a big deal to have an inalienable right to say anything that doesn't offend anybody.
Sorry, guys. Freedom of speech has to do with speech that some or all find offensive. Hardly a big deal to have an inalienable right to say anything that doesn't offend anybody.
Hmm …
… Is The “Creative Class” Dying? � The Dish. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
The notion of a creative class is almost oxymoronic. Individuals are creative, classes aren't. In Michel Houellebecq's Goncourt-winning novel The Map and the Territory, there is a nice take on the art scene:
[Jed] rapidly assimilated the appropriate behavior. It wasn't obligatory to be brilliant, and was actually best most often to say nothing at all, even if it was indispensable to listen to your interlocutor with seriousness and empathy, relaunching the conversation with a "Really?" meant to register interest and surprise, or a "That's for sure" colored with understanding and approval.
The notion of a creative class is almost oxymoronic. Individuals are creative, classes aren't. In Michel Houellebecq's Goncourt-winning novel The Map and the Territory, there is a nice take on the art scene:
[Jed] rapidly assimilated the appropriate behavior. It wasn't obligatory to be brilliant, and was actually best most often to say nothing at all, even if it was indispensable to listen to your interlocutor with seriousness and empathy, relaunching the conversation with a "Really?" meant to register interest and surprise, or a "That's for sure" colored with understanding and approval.
Executive Editor of the NYT gets...
ugly:
New York Times executive editor Dean Baquet called an associate professor at the USC Annenberg School an "asshole" on Facebook today after the professor took a shot at Baquet for not running Charlie Hebdo's Muhammed cartoons.
"Dear Marc," Baquet wrote to USC's Marc Cooper, "appreciate the self righteous second guessing without even considering there might be another point of view. Hope your students are more open minded. Asshole."
Reached via email, Baquet told POLITICO: "Lots of people have disagreed with my decision. Some of them are in The Times. I get that. Mr Cooper's comment was nasty and arrogant. So I told him what I thought."
Something to think on …
Every thing secret degenerates, even the administration of justice; nothing is safe that does not show how it can bear discussion and publicity.
— Lord Acton, born on this date in 1834
Friday, January 09, 2015
Hmm …
… Bruce Charlton's Miscellany: How to read James Joyce's Ulysses. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
This seems a minority. Many people can't get throught the first three chapters (some acquaintance with scholastic philosophy can help), and many skip to get to Mr. Bloom and his adventures.
This seems a minority. Many people can't get throught the first three chapters (some acquaintance with scholastic philosophy can help), and many skip to get to Mr. Bloom and his adventures.
Patrick Modiano
I had a long chat last week with Frank about Patrick Modiano, the French author who's been awarded the Nobel Prize.
Like many, I was not familiar with Modiano's oeuvre, despite the fact that he's put out a book a year for the past several decades.
And so, this week, I bought and read one of the few Modiano texts translated into English, Dora Bruder. I'll be writing a formal review of the book for Rain Taxi later this winter. For now, though, let me say: what a terribly sad work. But then, what a transcendent one, too.
Much like Sebald, Modiano lurks in the shadows, in those spaces overcome with tragedy and loss. I finished Dora Bruder in three sittings, and it's sure to stay with me. I'll publish a link to my review when it appears.
With Paris in the news so much this week, and with violence swirling around, there was something about reading Modiano at this moment - this exact moment - that seemed so perfectly, well, Modiano.
For here's an author who believes in connections across time and space. And to read his book about Paris now - about the city at a different time, of course, but under equally violent conditions - evoked that transcendent, almost eerie, quality for which Modiano must be known.
Let me highly recommend this book.
A telling scrap …
… Chance discovery casts new light on origins of polyphonic music | Music | The Guardian. (Hat tip, Sally Wiener Grotta.)
Indeed …
… Chris Hernandez Tells It Like It Is | The American Conservative. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
The journalists at Charlie Hebdo are now rightly being celebrated as martyrs on behalf of freedom of expression, but let’s face it: If they had tried to publish their satirical newspaper on any American university campus over the last two decades it wouldn’t have lasted 30 seconds. Student and faculty groups would have accused them of hate speech. The administration would have cut financing and shut them down.My, my. That's David Brooks. Good for him.
Sad, pure hypocrisy at the New York Times...
Mr. Baquet told me that he started out the day Wednesday convinced that The Times should publish the images, both because of their newsworthiness and out of a sense of solidarity with the slain journalists and the right of free expression.
He said he had spent “about half of my day” on the question, seeking out the views of senior editors and reaching out to reporters and editors in some of The Times’s international bureaus. They told him they would not feel endangered if The Times reproduced the images, he told me, but he remained concerned about staff safety.
“I sought out a lot of views, and I changed my mind twice,” he said. “It had to be my decision alone.”
Ultimately, he decided against it, he said, because he had to consider foremost the sensibilities of Times readers, especially its Muslim readers. To many of them, he said, depictions of the prophet Muhammad are sacrilegious; those that are meant to mock even more so. “We have a standard that is long held and that serves us well: that there is a line between gratuitous insult and satire. Most of these are gratuitous insult.”
And here is "Piss Christ", a Madonna covered in dung, and other shocking images featured in the Times...
I'd rather read Chesterton (or apparently Appleyard) in green crayon...
From the comments:
The problem with religion, the montheistic variety , is that you have to believe nonsense like holy ghosts , prophets ascending to heaven on winged chariots , original sin , threatening Gods , miracles , virgin births , the Universe created just for you and Jimmy Saville . Give me the natural world any time . GK was a bit of a bore like Bryan Appleyard . (Emphasis added)
Something to think on …
Let no one think that real gardening is a bucolic and meditative occupation. It is an insatiable passion, like everything else to which a man gives his heart.
— Karel Capek, born on this date in 1890
Thursday, January 08, 2015
Just a thought …
He wondered if maybe we shouldn't bother
Thinking. God in the garden was evident
And walked among us. Eve and Adam thought
Things over and acted on their own. And God
Went into hiding, leaving behind
Only clues to his whereabouts
Defending Murder...
...The truth is that Western governments are content to sacrifice liberties and freedoms when being complicit to torture and rendition — or when restricting the freedom of movement of Muslims, under the guise of protecting national security.
So why in this case did the French government allow the magazine Charlie Hebdo to continue to provoke Muslims, thereby placing the sanctity of its citizens at risk?
It is time that the sanctity of a Prophet revered by up to one-quarter of the world's population was protected.
And the New Yorker...
The Blame for the Charlie Hebdo Murders
...A religion is not just a set of texts but the living beliefs and practices of its adherents. Islam today includes a substantial minority of believers who countenance, if they don’t actually carry out, a degree of violence in the application of their convictions that is currently unique. Charlie Hebdo had been nondenominational in its satire, sticking its finger into the sensitivities of Jews and Christians, too—but only Muslims responded with threats and acts of terrorism. For some believers, the violence serves a will to absolute power in the name of God, which is a form of totalitarianism called Islamism—politics as religion, religion as politics. “Allahu Akbar!” the killers shouted in the street outside Charlie Hebdo. They, at any rate, know what they’re about.
Even the Onion is sad and angry
It is Sadly Unclear Whether This Article Will Put Lives At Risk
...At press time, although the consequences of this article are reportedly still unclear and actual human lives may hang in the balance, sources confirmed that the best thing to do—really the only thing to do—is to simply put it out there and just hope that it does some good.
An interesting list …
… My Top Ten Books of 2014 | Ajoobacats Blog.
I had breakfast yesterday with the author of The Winter Boy and her husband, both of whom are old friends.
I had breakfast yesterday with the author of The Winter Boy and her husband, both of whom are old friends.
Something to think on …
The only way to live is to accept each minute as an unrepeatable miracle, which is exactly what it is: a miracle and unrepeatable.
— Storm Jameson, born on this date in 1891
(Pseudo) Thought of the Day
It would be a lot easier to exercise free will if God had given me a brain that can focus for at least five seconds, rather than one that is like a hyperactive hummingbird.
Wednesday, January 07, 2015
This is the worst White House ever
On September 19, 2012 at the White House daily press briefing then press secretary Jay Carney condemned the judgement of Charlie Hebdo magazine for publishing “deeply offensive,” anti-Islamic cartoons.
RIP
“I’d rather die on my feet than live on my knees.” – Stephane “Charb” Charbonnier (1967 – 2015), publisher, Charlie Hebdo.
Q & A …
… My questions about Houellebecq’s “Submission” answered - The Unz Review. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
Methinks, after events today in Paris, widespread Sympathy for Islam among natives is unlikely.
Methinks, after events today in Paris, widespread Sympathy for Islam among natives is unlikely.
Something to think on …
A word is not the same with one writer as with another. One tears it from his guts. The other pulls it out of his overcoat pocket.
— Charles Peguy, born on this date in 1873
Tuesday, January 06, 2015
The NYT is relevant and stronger than ever!!!!
says the executive editor, Dean Baquet and is "the best news organization in the world."
From the comments:
From the comments:
When the NYT is no longer the best news organization in the world, how will we know?
I would argue that cooking apps and sponsored news content are strong evidence.
But most of all, it is the feebleness of the other contenders that makes the NYT exemplary. The best news organizations in the world all expired a generation ago. The Times has fallen far and fast, but the rest have plummeted.
Our souls …
… What We Lose if We Lose the Canon - The Chronicle Review - The Chronicle of Higher Education. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)
A few decades ago the modernists themselves became precursors when a loose confederation of critics and philosophers decided that modernism consisted of work that was too oblique and too self-consciously "high art" while remaining at the same time innocent of its own socio-semiotic implications. But what made the postmodern charter different was its willingness to discard the very idea of standards. Starting from the premise that aesthetics were just another social construct rather than a product of universal principles, postmodernist thinkers succeeded in toppling hierarchies and nullifying the literary canon. Indeed, they were so good at unearthing the socioeconomic considerations behind canon formation that even unapologetic highbrows had to wonder if they hadn’t been bamboozled by Arnoldian acolytes and eloquent ideologues.A necessary consequence of too many ordinary intellects managing to wangle for themselves a Ph. D.
I take a very latitudinarian view of literature and culture. I think an acquaintance with Homer, Sophocles, and Plato is essential if you want your mind to be situated within a temporal context that is both broad and deep. But there are quite of few such from quite a few different eras. It is also essential to read Montaigne, Dr. Johnson, and Walter Pater. If you like crime fiction and have not read The Moonstone, you should not read another crime novel until you have. The house of literature has many mansions.
Question most valid...
...I love books so why do I hate studying English GCSE?
We need to inject creativity back in the classroom, we need a route of learning that can inspire. We need books that bring up intense messages of modern themes: sexism, racism, homosexuality. I strongly believe literature is the route to giving teenagers a voice about these themes. It’s not even like these books don’t exist; I can think of hundreds on the spot. Highlights in my classroom are the debates we have, where people who otherwise sit in a corner and highlight their pages have their voices heard after being inspired by literature. This year, every sentence analysed goes towards an exam. To gain full marks, it’s all about knowing what to write, how to analyse – and the sad thing is that this is how intelligence is now measured. By how well you can describe the effect of the iambic pentameter, not by a real opinion on Romeo’s values or how substantial his love really is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



