Tuesday, September 16, 2014

Imperfectly phrased …

… The Sense of Style by Steven Pinker, review: 'waffle and bilge' — Telegraph. (Hat tip, Dave Lull.)

If you had to boil down Pinker’s advice into two main points, they would be: “Keep it snappy” and “Keep it simple”. Unfortunately, he proves wholly incapable of abiding by his own rules. Rather, he’s a colossal windbag, never using three words when 35 can be rammed into the breach, and frequently writing sentences so tortuous that they seem to be eating themselves. He even manages to define what a coherent text is in a way that made my eyeballs rotate in opposite directions: “A coherent text is one in which the reader always knows which coherence relation holds between one sentence and the next.”

No comments:

Post a Comment